The Smearing of Amanda Knox Shows Reading News Critically is Critical

Amanda Knox is not really a political story, but I happened on a well-articulated article about the news reporting of Amanda Knox’s diary. This article by Amanda Knox biographer Candace Dempsey, gives a great example of why it is important to read the news critically.

A Ms. Dempsey notes, newspapers have been fond of creating headlines like

“Amanda Knox compares herself to Helen of Troy.”

But, what is the real story? Here is the diary entry:  Jeez, I’m not even that good-looking! People are acting like I’m the prettiest thing since Helen of Troy!”

Or, there was another headline that read:

“I got 23 fan letters from guys today: Foxy Knox’s disturbing diary.”

What’s the real story? Dempsey reports: On Nov. 19, she does mentions that she got 23 “fan letters” that “the jail had been saving up for me.”

These examples are representative of the terrible failing we have now have of peopling writing under the pretense of journalistic credibility. They will take and twist the facts to sensationalize the story for more ratings.  Yet, we still like to believe that they are journalists who hold themselves to some level objectivity and honesty. Sure, no one is without bias, but there is difference between striving for objectivity and striving to win a point or stir people up. Unfortunately, journalistic ethics have largely gone out the window as profession and are never coming back. Or maybe it was a myth that they existed. At any rate, what it means for us is that we have to always look behind the headline or sound bite and find the evidence for it.

Leave a Comment